Here we have the 5th studio LP from Lexington, Kentucky singer/songwriter, dancer & actress Tinashe. Breaking out over a decade ago off her first 3 mixtapes In Case We Die as well as Reverie & more specifically Black Water, her RCA Records-backed debut Aquarius was as well received as the latter although her debut EP Amethyst was moderately received & the 4th tape Nightride was seen as an improvement. She would later depart RCA following the sophomore effort Joyride going independent on both Songs for You & 333respectively to better reception again, coming off BB/Ang3l & Quantum Baby to sign with Atlantic Records for Popstar.
“Sunglasses” produced by Arca kicks things off singing about seeing straightforward tunnel vision whereas “Too Easy” blends ghettotech, pop rap & techno bass boasting that she makes this shit look simple. “Melatonin” could have a chance at becoming the best single of 2026 masterfully combining ghetto house, ghettotech, acid techno, electroclash, tech house & hip house singing about those sleeping on her prior to “Empty Stadium” sampling “Rebound” by Audrey Nuna describing the rush she gets when rehearsing.
We have Tinashe taking a more somber approach during “Flashbacks” apologizing to her partner for talking shit whenever she gets turned on while the 44 second “Overdramatic” feels underdeveloped because I really enjoy DJ Camper’s jazzy trap beat & the brief verse. “I’d Rather Be Alone” mixes elements of trap & alternative R&B depicting the unwillingness of continuing an unhappy relationship while “Crash Out” experiments with ratchet & hyphy retaining the PBR&B & pop rap textures losing her shit.
“Pillow Fight” begins the 2nd half showing a more playful side to herself singing about falling in love with someone instantly while “Nobody Wanna Dance Anymore” goes EDM to make some commentary regarding that specific scene that’s others have made equally well. “25/8” atmospherically finds herself going beyond the limits daily while & after the “The Show Must Go On” intermission, the title track brings us to the core advising against dating a Popstar.
The song “Brainrot” makes a bold comparison between her numbness towards insincere affection & the Internet culture phase popularized by Gen Z & Alpha that I found to be genuinely funny while “Cloud 9” warmly sings about being in paradise with basslines that keep hitting you in the chest. “Heavy Weight” spends the remaining minutes of the album stripping it back for an acoustic outro confessing she’s been carrying this baggage for some time.
Returning to a major label for the first time in almost a decade, Atlantic makes it up to everyone for the mediocre responses to Miley Cyrus’ own debut for the imprint Bass Persuades last weekend with what I’m sure many will consider Tinashe’s finest artistic statement for years to come. The alternative R&B, electronic dance music, post-dubstep, pop rap, alt-pop & UK bass production embodies her own definition of what makes a Popstar & she sounds more confident than she has previously.
Score: 4.5/5
Keep up with @legendswill_never_die on Instagram & @LegendsllLiveOn on Twitter for the best music reviews weekly!
